Suggestion for vehicles to use instead of Strykers in 1st Platoon

By SPC D.Scott , 22 hours ago
  • 22 hours ago Edited on 21 hours ago by SPC D.Scott

    1. Purpose

    The purpose of this is to suggest that JLTV's or HMMWVs be tested and utilized as primary squad transport vehicles in Arma Reforger during the current Field Training Exercise (FTX) period, in place of the Stryker platform, due to observed technical and gameplay limitations.


    2. Background

    The unit is currently operating within an FTX-focused training cycle, where realism, situational awareness, and effective command-and-control are critical. During this period, the Stryker vehicle mod available in Arma Reforger has demonstrated multiple limitations that negatively impact squad-level training and leadership execution.


    3. Discussion

    The following issues have been consistently observed when employing the Stryker during training events:

    1. Squad members are unable to turn out, unlike functionality previously available in Arma 3
    2. Restricted visibility across all crew positions
    3. Squad Leaders must occupy the gunner position to maintain situational awareness, reducing their ability to lead effectively
    4. Drivers are locked into a fixed window view and cannot look left or right
    5. Passengers are unable to observe, identify, or react to external threats

    These limitations significantly degrade the Stryker’s effectiveness during all operational scenarios where situational awareness and leadership decision-making are essential.

    In contrast, JLTV's and HMMWVs currently provide improved performance within Arma Reforger, offering:

    1. Superior situational awareness for drivers, leaders and other squad members
    2. Greater command flexibility for Squad Leaders
    3. More consistent and intuitive vehicle behavior
    4. The ability to transport up to seven squad members in a single HMMWV, allowing cohesive squad maneuver during training

    From a realism perspective, this suggestion aligns with real-world practices. While the U.S. Army 3rd Infantry Division after my understanding is a heavy armored division employing Abrams and/or Bradley platforms, it also routinely utilizes HMMWVs and JLTVs for patrols, convoy operations, security missions, and dismounted infantry support—particularly outside full mechanized operations.


    4. Recommendation

    It is recommended that the unit conduct a formal test of JLTVs or HMMWVs as squad transport vehicles during the current FTX period, allowing leadership to evaluate their effectiveness compared to the Stryker platform. This test should be treated as a temporary measure and reassessed following completion of the FTX cycle.

    Hummwv


    JLTV

    Stryker


    5. Conclusion

    Testing JLTVs or HMMWVs during the current FTX period would allow the unit to make an informed decision based on performance, realism, and leadership effectiveness. This approach supports mission success while allowing flexibility to return to Stryker usage once the platform reaches a more complete and functional state.


    Respectfully submitted,

    Specialist Dennis Scott

    Alpha Company, 1st Platoon, 2nd Squad